It’s Not Really SEO That You Hate

SEO-provides-actionsI had an interesting experience the other day while doing some online research. I ran across a website discussing why writers and content marketers hate SEO. As a writer myself, that was news to me. Hoping it was a lone opinion I did some searching. I discovered pages upon pages of discussions about how SEO forces writers to create bad content and punishes those who write well.

Now, I know I don’t hate SEO, so I asked our Senior Copywriter Nathan Williams, who leads content marketing initiatives for clients in a wide range of industries, for his feelings on the subject. Here’s what he had to say:

“It’s interesting that a copywriter would say they hate SEO, because the two work hand-in-hand, at least in my experience. From the copywriting perspective, SEO is the afterthought. If the SEO tactics are on the level, the copywriter just has to make sure the keywords won’t disrupt the flow or distract from the point.

It’s not fair to say that copywriters hate SEO, because that opinion is painting with a really wide brush. And there’s no need to feel that way. SEO provides actions, targets and priorities, and copywriters use that information to tailor the content. The two sides must work together, or both fail.”

What SEO Copywriting Isn’t

Nathan’s point really emphasizes what separates true SEO from the kind of black hat tactics that give websites a brief bump followed by a long, hard fall. There’s a mindset out there that search is a system to be gamed, and for some reason a terrifyingly large number of people in the SEO biz think that gaming that system is a better choice than working within it.

That’s why you’ll still find sites out there hiring bargain basement copywriters with no real skill or experience, and using spinning software to create meaningless, garbage content. Meanwhile behind-the-scenes they are buying links, hiding keywords in code, and participating in all sorts of unsavory practices meant to trick search engines and serve up content that does not answer the question posed in the search query.

The real irony in this is that they are likely putting more effort into those tactics than we on the white hat, ethical SEO side are by just following the rules and creating quality content.

It’s Not SEO’s Fault

Keyword stuffing and creating nothing content around random terms is not what we signed on for, and the results are not what clients sign on for, either. Any copywriter is going to be unhappy in a system like that.

But what Nathan talked about, and what the rest of us who work on the copywriting side here at SEO Advantage know, is that when your behind the scenes SEO and coding folks are doing their jobs well, all you really have to do is write relevant content with a few placement adjustments here or there. We probably spend less than 10% of our copywriting time thinking about keywords, because if what you are writing truly speaks to the question asked in the search query, the keywords don’t have to be stuffed. They flow organically.

If, as a copywriter, you find yourself at odds with SEO, then the problem likely isn’t with the system itself, but with the way you are being asked to manipulate it.

Google Will Now Include Panda in its Real-Time Algorithm

Up until now, Google’s “Panda” was just a periodic update by the search giant to ferret out sites engaging in spam and other nefarious activities. Over the last couple of years, many websites have lost rankings due to the update.

In a Q&A session at the SMX conference earlier this week, Google spam chief Matt Cutts was asked when the next Panda update would occur.

He answered that it would occur either today (March 15), or Monday March 18th at the latest.

A brief recap of Panda

Following an update in late 2009 aimed at improving its indexing process, Google obtained lots of content to display in their search results. Some of this content was really good, some not so good. In commenting about the events of 2010 and 2011 leading up to Panda, Cutts explained that many sites were taking a minimalist approach to content, meaning they were making only token efforts to avoid being labeled “spam.”

To address this issue and provide better search results for their users, Google unveiled the Panda update in February 2011. One thing became clear during all of this – Google was using more human reviewers to determine if a site is “trustworthy.”

Sites who simply rehashed content found elsewhere, or who otherwise had “low-quality” content, were suddenly being knocked lower in the rankings. Google would run this update every month or so – with the last one occurring on January 22nd that affected 1.2% of English-based searches.

Going forward, Google will be including the Panda “parameters” in its real-time algorithm.

“Rather than having some huge change that happens on a given day, you’re more likely in the future to see Panda deployed gradually as we’re rebuilding the index, so you’re less likely to see these large scale sorts of changes,” explained Cutts last week at SMX West.

Google also working to revise its “Penguin” update

Besides the content based Panda update, Cutts also indicated Google would be going after spammers more aggressively through a revised “Penguin” update. You might remember Penguin from last year – it targeted sites considered to be “over-optimized.” Examples include:

  • Questionable linking practices
  • Overuse of exact-match domains
  • Aggressive use of exact-match anchor text
  • Keyword stuffing in internal/outbound links
  • And more…

Explaining the new Penguin update at SMX West, Cutts says the update will be the most significant one for 2013. He says the anti-spam team at Google also plans to target more link networks this year. While Cutts was fairly forthright about their plans, he didn’t provide a timeline of when the new Penguin update would hit.

With that said, it’s clear that we’ll likely see some pretty significant activity on the Google front in the next few months. Many sites and merchants on Google will undoubtedly be negatively affected.

How do I avoid being caught in the Google penalty box?

From what we can tell, Google’s primary goal is to provide useful results to their users. These search results must provide valuable information to readers.

Therefore, you should ensure that content you’re developing is unique, and provides value to your site visitors. You should also follow good linking practices to ensure you’re not snared by the new Penguin update when it comes out.

Following tips on linking and content found here at SEO-e is perhaps the best thing you can do to avoid being penalized. Check out some of the links below of prior posts exploring these best practices.

And please browse around our blog for more insights into what Google looks for, and how they penalize sites that do not meet their strict standards.

Related Posts

Penguin Update Targets Link Schemes and Low-Quality Content

Link Building in the Post-Penguin World – Guest Posting

Answer these 23 Questions to Understand What Google Looks For

3 Steps You Should Take Before Linking to another Site

 

Friday Trivia: Understanding Bounce Rates

Welcome to SEO Advantage’s Friday Trivia feature, where we discuss, dissect and comment on the internet and marketing, and how the two intertwine.

Ah, the dreaded bounce rate. It’s that unpleasant little number that lets you know that no matter how many visitors you get to your page, some just aren’t going to stick around to see the rest of your site. This can happen for a number of reasons, though, and not all of them are bad. Do you know the average bounce rate for web pages?

  1. 20%
  2. 40%
  3. 60%
  4. 80%

Answer: 40%

According to Google, Kissmetrics and just about every other source on the internet, the average bounce rate for a web page is about 40%. Whether that’s higher or lower than what you usually see, though, is less important than determining what that bounce rate means for that specific page.

When high bounce rates might not be so bad

Sometimes a high bounce rate might actually mean you’re doing something right. This is especially true of informational pages like knowledge centers, blog posts and even directory listings.

If you’re putting information out there on a page optimized for search with content that directly answers the question posed by the keyword phrases you’re targeting, then you’ve given visitors what they want. They search, come to the page, get the answer to their question and leave satisfied. This isn’t bad from a marketing standpoint, either, because the next time that visitor has a question or needs what your business offers related to that topic, chances are they’ll remember you.

In some cases, bounces might also indicate quality leads. If you host an offsite blog linking to your business home page and that blog has a high bounce rate, visitors may very well be bouncing right where you want them to go. Are you getting a lot of referrals to the main site from the blog? If so, then your blog is doing its job.

A high bounce rate may also be benign for a business website. If you’re observing web design best practices, your contact information is prominently displayed on every page of the site. Bounces in this case could indicate that visitors liked what they saw and took the next step.

In short, if your content is robust, high-quality and relevant to the keywords that are bringing in visitors, a high bounce rate is likely nothing to worry about, and possibly even a good sign.

When to worry about a high bounce rate

Reassurances aside, there are some situations where a high bounce rate really is a no good, very bad thing. The most common occurrence of this: the landing page. If you’ve created a page specifically to bring in visitors with the intention of having them purchase a product or sign up for a service, and those visitors then bounce without buying, browsing or signing up, it’s time to optimize that landing page.

You should also be concerned when high bounce rates correspond with shorter visits. If you’ve written a robust information piece but visitors are spending an average of 30 seconds or less on the page and then leaving your site entirely, it usually indicates that you are either offering information that’s irrelevant to the keywords or your content itself is problematic. It may be too generic, or it may simply be poorly written and difficult to read. If you really want to fix these types of issues, get ready to set aside your ego and get self-critical.

Every page is different

What makes understanding bounce rates so confusing for some is that every page and type of content is different, and you won’t learn anything from analyzing bounce rates in a vacuum. You need to understand how to interpret bounce rates as they relate to your other metrics and the page’s purpose and content.

So, did you guess the right answer? How do you use bounce rate to help you optimize your SEO and online marketing?

Getting to Know Your SEO: An Interview with SEOA’s Stone Reuning

Stone Reuning has been doing SEO since the pre-Google era, back when Yahoo was the king of search. That alone would be impressive, but it’s really just part of the story.

When it comes to decision support cred, it doesn’t get much better than Ernst & Young, and that was only one stop along Stone’s 25-year career in consulting and business services. He and his brother Wes – an SEO Advantage partner and Executive VP – both worked with Fortune 500 companies before teaming up to form Tampa Bay Associates, where they developed and implemented business solutions. Then, in 1999, the Reuning brothers created the venture that would become one of the internet’s most innovative and successful SEO companies: SEO Advantage.

Stone and I “sat down together” in the virtual office this week, and he told me the story of how SEO Advantage was formed, and how Stone and Wes saw an opportunity and seized it at a time when SEO and mainstream internet use were still in their infancy.

The Reuning brothers were specializing in medical systems in the late 90’s, back before Google took over the search world. “We were going to move our healthcare company into the internet arena,” Stone explained, “but within weeks it became obvious that if we wanted to make this work we needed to get this website to the top of Yahoo and Alta Vista, and in front of the CEOs of hospitals. We were looking at providing software for healthcare businesses, but once we started to develop the website we saw an opportunity to do something new that every business would need. Making that progression was natural for me, because succeeding on the internet was just another math problem.”

Thus SEO Advantage was born, and in the years since it has stayed on the forefront of every SEO development, adapting to algorithm updates when necessary, but usually surviving those updates relatively unscathed. This is a credit to Stone’s forward-thinking leadership and ability to see the future of search before it happens. It’s also the direct result of the fact that, unlike many SEO executives who become completely disconnected from the day-to-day operations of their companies, Stone works in the trenches. He remains directly involved with every single client SEO Advantage serves.

I asked him how he maintains that passion, and it became immediately obvious why managing from on high is not and never will be his style. “My main interest has always been in product development,” he told me.  “I enjoy developing new approaches, looking at math, and making things work in a profitable way. How do we make systems work, and how do we make them work better?”

“I’ve always viewed clients as business partners,” he continued, “I ask them, ‘what are your problems? What are the things you’re trying to solve? What keeps you up at night?’ I like to form long-term relationships with clients. Some have been with us for over a decade. Building these relationships, to me, is the right way to do business.” Considering SEO Advantage’s success, that’s not just an opinion. The company’s record has been proven time and time again, to the benefit of clients in fields from law to medicine to precious metals.

Another contributing factor to that success is the company culture that has evolved over the years. SEO Advantage employs a virtual office approach, and although Stone is hands-on with every client, he doesn’t micromanage, preferring to give his employees a sense of ownership over their work.

“I think it says a lot about who we are as an internet-based company that we fully utilize online resources as part of our day-to-day operations. We aren’t constrained by geography. We find and hire talent from all over the U.S., giving our clients the advantage of the most skilled, experienced staff available. Our approach breeds creativity and attracts people who are driven and self-motivated outside of a traditional office environment. It also keeps down our overhead, which is great from the client perspective.”

When asked to name the number one aspect of SEO Advantage that gives it a decided edge over other SEO companies, Stone didn’t hesitate. “Our team,” He said immediately. “Early in my career, one of my supervisors said to me, ‘I want you to basically do my job so that I can go do another job.’ That stuck with me, and that’s why I’ve focused on building a company of managers. SEO technicians who are used to following someone else’s instructions to the letter wouldn’t fit in here. I want managers who are invested in their work, and I find that giving passionate people autonomy makes it fun for everyone, which in turn promotes even more creativity and innovation.”

Next I asked Stone to name the best and worst developments in SEO over his career. His answer: “Google and Google.”

“SEO was easier when we started. Companies could get people to rank with spam, but the long-term value of that approach was short lived even back then. It would make people rank, but it didn’t actually produce revenue. It’s more complex for us, but it’s also better for the people using the internet.”

“I’ve always gravitated toward what Google reinforces,” he continued, “and we’ve always been much more on the messaging side of things. It’s nice these days to not have to compete with the spammers, so while Google makes it more complex, it’s actually easier for us, because we never became dependent on those sorts of tactics.”

To wind things down on a casual note, I asked Stone what was the one thing he couldn’t work without during the day. I expected him to say something like coffee or music, but instead I got one more indicator of how passionate he is about his work.

“The newness of the SEO problem,” he answered. “I’m a math geek. I like trying to figure out new approaches with the math. The internet’s even better than a math problem, though. It’s the biggest math problem. You have to infer, figure things out. For me, growing businesses is fun.”

That approach and attitude pretty much sum up how SEO Advantage operates, and why the company has been so successful in developing new approaches to search marketing for our clients over the years. “Growing businesses is fun.”

Link Building Post Panda – Is Article Marketing Still Viable?

The short answer is yes, if you’re mindful of the needs of your audience and make quality over quantity the core of your link building efforts…

In the early days of online marketing and SEO, syndicating articles through directory sites like Article Alley was an effective way of generating links and building rankings.

Over time though, whole software and online marketing tools made this task very easy – some even go as far to generate content automatically. Spinning software is another tool available that takes an article and modifies the keywords. While some phrases may be different, the piece is essentially the same.

As the Google algorithm has taken a more critical eye toward content, the effectiveness and legitimacy of this tactic has considerably waned.

The term article marketing, as seen in this video from SEOMoz, has in fact taken on quite a nasty meaning in recent years.

Wistia


Because the term has been tarnished though doesn’t mean article marketing isn’t a viable strategy – that is if you do it properly and not overly rely on links from the lower quality article directory sites.

To better understand the best way to approach article marketing for link building purposes, you should first understand why the old way of looking at article marketing doesn’t work anymore.

1.     Article directory sites offer low-quality links – Google’s Panda/Farmer updates in 2010-2011 dramatically reduced the value of links from article directory sites.

2.     Duplicate content – Submitting the same content to multiple sites leads to duplicate content filters, rendering the links worthless

3.     Readers and search engines are more discriminating – As the web has developed, so have its users, who demand more informative, easy to understand content. Realizing this, search engines work to filter out content that is blatantly link building in nature.

Therefore, writing one piece and distributing to multiple, even hundreds of sites, or using “spinning” software to make multiple keyword variations on the same piece isn’t just ineffective, it’s potentially damaging in that it will make your business appear not so reputable.

Link Building through Article Marketing in 2013 and beyond

Having the ability to build anchor-text links to the exact pages you want, when you want, is still extremely valuable. If you have a high-level page targeting a valuable keyword, you want to get as many high-quality links you can.

High-quality being the operative word of course…

Article marketing and guest posting is one of several ways to get these links. You can see some of our prior discussion on guest posting below.

Speaking of article marketing more broadly though, you can still target content to relevant sites looking for outside contributors and guest content. The best approach is to find the best sites in your niche’ and create direct relationships with them.

Some ways you can find these sites include:

1.      Combine your top keywords with phrases commonly found on sites looking for guest content. These phrases include – looking for writers, guest blogger, submit an article, contribute content, write an article, and others.

If you’re an e-cigarette retailer for example, you could enter “e-cigarette” + “looking for writers” into a search to find good sites.

2.          Search through DMOZ and Google directories for more authoritative, trusted sites. Any site you find in one or both of these directories have already gone through an editorial review, so you can trust them more.

3.          See where other authors are publishing their content. If you’re visiting an article directory site, enter an author’s name in a Google search to see all of the sites where their work is featured.

I understand how I can find good sites to post content for link building purposes, but how do I find the time to actually write the articles, blog posts, etc. etc.?

If you’re focusing on quality over quantity, you will of course have to be able to generate the content. Software tools that automatically generate or “spin” the content are no good since the copy typically doesn’t reflect what an actual person would write.

Producing quality content does take a little bit of effort, but the benefits of thinking quality over quantity cannot be overstated.

One approach you can consider for producing content is to write an article on your target topic/keywords. Set that piece aside, and write a second piece on the same topic, without looking at your original. You can do this several times over in fact.

This approach can help you write pieces very quickly since they’re on a topic you’re already familiar with. But in order for you to make them unique, you absolutely cannot look at the prior drafts.

How about your efforts to build links through article marketing and guest posting?

Have you had to change your approach following Google’s big updates of the last couple of years?

What sort of challenges have you run into with article marketing, and link building in general?

We want to hear from you – please feel free to leave us a comment below, or on our Facebook, Google+ or Twitter feed today.

Related Posts

 Penguin Update Targets Link Schemes and Low-Quality Content

Google Panda Update Causes Some Sites to Lose Traffic, Revenues

Link Building in the Post Penguin World – Guest Posting